Does Giovanni's Magikarp (1st Edition) have positive grading EV?

Based on current pricing, our model estimates a negative grading EV of $1.60 for Giovanni's Magikarp (1st Edition) — grading costs currently exceed the estimated PSA-10 premium. This is a model estimate based on historical data, not investment advice.

What is the estimated grading EV for Giovanni's Magikarp (1st Edition)?

Our model estimates approximately 5% return after grading costs, based on historical grade distributions and recent sold comps. Raw price: $13.14, estimated grading cost: ~$22.00, estimated EV: $1.60. Estimates are informational, not investment advice; trading cards are not securities.

Should You Grade Giovanni's Magikarp (1st Edition)?

Gym Challenge · #73

Expected-value figures are estimates based on historical grade distributions and market prices. Not a recommendation. Grading outcomes and market prices are not guaranteed. Methodology · Full disclaimer

Estimated grading EV negative

Current grading costs exceed model estimate of PSA 10 premium

Expected Value

Raw price$13.14

Grading cost~$22.00

Blended EV$14.74

Estimated profit$1.60

Estimated return5%

Break-even sell price$36.73

Profit by Grade

PSA 6 $21.80 $-13.34 (-38%)

PSA 7 $22.10 $-13.04 (-37%)