Skip to content

Excellent vs Greptile: the review bot that really does run code

TREX really does run tests in a sandbox. The difference is the attempt record, not the execution.

curl -fsSL https://excellent.so/install.sh | sh
Jump to comparison

Greptile in one line

An AI reviewer that builds a graph of your codebase and runs a “swarm” review on each pull request, learning from your team's comments. Its TREX agent writes and runs tests in a sandbox, and it ships a Claude Code plugin, an MCP server and /greploop.

Best for
Teams that want whole-repository review context and a reviewer that can validate a change at runtime without them building the harness first.
Limits
TREX validates a change; it does not keep the history of what the agent tried. There is no attempt record, and no held-out trial when you change the agent's prompt, model or tools.
Stronger than us at
This is the fairest fight on the site and we are not going to pretend otherwise. Greptile is stronger in three places: its code graph gives it whole-codebase review context Excellent does not have; TREX writes the tests it runs, and we write none; and its distribution is at a scale we are nowhere near.
Price 2026-09-23
$30 / seat / mo (Pro, 50 credits per seat)

Excellent in one line

A verification system for agentic tasks. It records what the agent attempted, runs your checks against the claim, and binds the result to evidence you can open.

Best for
Teams that want agent work checked before they trust or promote it.
Limits
There is no hosted option. You run it on your machines. Verification evidence stays on the machine that produced it and does not sync to teammates yet. No SSO, and no Mac app has shipped. It does not write tests, and it does not review your diff.
Stronger than them at
Keeping the attempt record, running your own checks as the oracle, and trialling prompt, model and tool changes on held-out work from your repository.
Price 2026-09-23
Free to install and run (Consulting from $10,000 / month)

The capabilities that decide it

Capability by capability, with Greptile on the left and Excellent on the right. Prices are the vendor's own, read on 2026-09-23.

CapabilityGreptileExcellent
Runs code to check a changeThis is the one review bot where the honest answer to “does it execute anything” is yes.Yes: TREX writes and runs tests in a sandboxYes
Whole-codebase review contextExcellent checks a specific attempt against specific checks. It does not build a graph of your repository.YesNo
Records each agent attempt and the claim it madeNoYes
Evidence beyond sandboxed testsSandboxed test runsTests, builds, browser checks and your existing GitHub Actions or GitLab CI
Tests prompt, model and tool changes on held-out workNoYes
Where it runsSandbox on Greptile's side; Claude Code plugin and MCP server availableLocal CLI and MCP; checks run on your machines
Published price (checked 2026-09-23)Starter free (50 credits per month); Pro $30 per seat per month with 50 credits per seat, extra credits $1 each; a TREX review costs 3 credits against 1 for a standard review; Enterprise customFree to install and run. Consulting starts at $10,000 / month.

When to pick which

Greptile is the closest thing in the review category to what we do, and if you want a reviewer that can actually run something, TREX does that today. Pick Excellent when the question stops being “is this diff OK” and becomes “what did the agent try, what proved it, and can someone outside the team replay that later.”

Pick Greptile if

Teams that want whole-repository review context and a reviewer that can validate a change at runtime without them building the harness first.

Add Excellent if

You want agent work captured as attempts, checked against evidence you can open, and promoted only when the result is defensible to someone outside the team.

Still shopping? See the full list of Greptile alternatives

Trust the evidence, not the agent's word

curl -fsSL https://excellent.so/install.sh | sh